Constitutional Court strikes down Sindh, KP infrastructure cess
The Federal Constitutional Court has set aside High Court rulings that had upheld the infrastructure cess in Sindh and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa. It held that the provincial laws fall outside the provinces' constitutional powers.

- The Federal Constitutional Court declared the Sindh and KP infrastructure cess laws unconstitutional.
- The Sindh High Court and Peshawar High Court rulings upholding the cess were set aside.
- The detailed judgment will be issued later.
The Federal Constitutional Court (FCC) has declared the infrastructure cess imposed by Sindh and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa unconstitutional, according to Express News, 24 News and Daily Pakistan. The court said the relevant provincial legislation is beyond the constitutional jurisdiction of the provinces.
A two-member bench headed by Chief Justice Amin-ud-Din Khan, with Justice Amir Farooq, issued the short decision. It set aside earlier judgments of the Sindh High Court and the Peshawar High Court, both of which had upheld the provincial laws.
The cases were brought by importers, exporters, industrialists and other taxpayers. They argued that the levies, by their nature and the way they are collected, concern matters on the federal legislative list. The petitioners said the cess is in effect an export duty, which only the federal government can impose. Appeals had gone to the Supreme Court before the cases were moved to the FCC.
Sindh collected its cess under the Sindh Development and Maintenance Infrastructure Cess Act 2017. Khyber Pakhtunkhwa did so under the KP Infrastructure Development Cess 2022 Act, which the Finance Act 2024 amended. Daily Jang reported that the court also declared Punjab's cess unconstitutional, a detail the other reports do not mention.
Hafiz Ehsan Ahmad Khokhar, appearing for the Revenue Division and the Federal Board of Revenue, argued that Parliament has exclusive power over imports, exports, international trade and customs duties. The Additional Attorney General also opposed the provincial laws, saying the provinces had no constitutional authority over these matters.
The Sindh and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa governments defended the cess as a charge for provincial roads, transport and infrastructure development and for the safe movement of goods.
According to the FBR's counsel, the cess raised production costs for manufacturers and exporters and made Pakistani products less competitive internationally. He said removing it would lower business costs and help them compete in global and regional markets. The court will issue its detailed judgment later.
Background
khabr.pk reported on 9 November that the Federal Constitutional Court had set six principles for vetting candidates for government jobs. Its rulings have recently covered a range of public-interest matters.
Why it matters for Pakistan
The ruling decides whether provinces or the federal government can levy a charge on goods moving through Sindh and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa. Importers, exporters and manufacturers who challenged the cess are directly affected. The FBR's counsel told the court the levy raised production costs and weakened exporters' competitiveness. The provincial governments had defended it as a charge for roads and infrastructure.
Get khabr.pk news on Facebook and YouTube
Short news videos every day, and the day’s top stories in your feed.



