Just in
PakistanVerified by 2 independent sources

Shazia Marri asks Talal Chaudhry why 27th Amendment passed by numbers

PPP's Shazia Marri asked State Minister Talal Chaudhry to explain why the 27th Amendment was passed by numerical majority and not political consensus. She also said the party does not support dividing provinces by unconstitutional means.

Shazia Marri asks Talal Chaudhry why 27th Amendment passed by numbers
Photo: Sohail Shahzad / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 4.0
KEY POINTS
  • Shazia Marri responded to a statement by State Minister for Interior Talal Chaudhry.
  • She asked why the 27th Amendment was passed by numbers, not consensus.
  • She said the Sindh Assembly has rejected division of Sindh several times.
  • She said Sindh provides about 585 billion rupees in additional financial assistance to the federation.
about 585 billion rupeesSindh's additional financial assistance to the federation, per Marri

Pakistan Peoples Party information secretary and National Assembly member Shazia Marri has asked State Minister for Interior Talal Chaudhry to explain why the 27th constitutional amendment was passed by numerical majority rather than political consensus, according to Express News and Daily Pakistan.

Responding in Karachi to the minister's statement, Marri said the PPP does not believe in dividing provinces through political maneuvering or unconstitutional means. She said the PPP had not raised the topics of system failure, a political reset or dividing provinces, and that the minister had raised them.

On Sindh, Marri said the Sindh Assembly had several times rejected the division of the province through constitutional means. She asked the minister to explain, in her words, why the division of Sindh was being discussed without taking the people of Sindh and their elected representatives into confidence.

Marri said Sindh provides about 585 billion rupees in additional financial assistance to the federation. She said the federal government should answer for not fulfilling the financial and constitutional rights of the provinces, and that it cannot blame provinces for every administrative problem while taking their resources and weakening their autonomy.

She also asked why the federal government was questioning provincial autonomy if the 18th Amendment is a historic achievement.

On the opposition's role, Marri said the opposition has a right to speak in a democracy and that disagreement is not a crime. She asked why it was being denied legitimate representation and voice in parliament. Of the party's views, she said: "Have we only given our opinion, is there now a ban on expression too?"

Marri said PPP chairman Bilawal Bhutto Zardari is demanding the supremacy of the constitution, not political concessions or special privileges. She said he had said the system did not collapse on its own but was brought to this state by those weakening democratic institutions, and that he has always stressed focusing on public problems such as inflation, poverty and unemployment.

A PPP spokesperson said the government should respond to democratic dialogue rather than personal attacks. The party says it believes in the supremacy of parliament, provincial autonomy and constitutional democracy.

Background

khabr.pk reported on 17 November that Bilawal Bhutto Zardari called for a political reset, saying the system was deliberately dismantled. On 18 November it reported that the International Commission of Jurists said the 26th and 27th amendments have eroded the independence of Pakistan's highest courts. It also reported on 18 November that Defence Minister Khawaja Asif questioned the PPP's record in Sindh in reply to Bilawal.

Why it matters for Pakistan

The 27th Amendment concerns how the country is governed and how courts and institutions work, so the dispute over how it was passed bears on all citizens. Sindh's residents are directly concerned by the debate over dividing the province and over the provincial share of resources. Marri's figure of about 585 billion rupees is her claim about Sindh's contribution to the federation, and the federal government has the chance to respond.

Report an error

PPP27th AmendmentSindh

Related news

Latest