Just in
PakistanVerified by 3 independent sources

Supreme Court disposes of Imaan Mazari, Hadi Chattha trial appeals as infructuous

The Supreme Court has disposed of appeals against the trial of lawyers Imaan Mazari and Hadi Ali Chattha in the barriers removal case. It called them infructuous because the trial had already finished.

Supreme Court disposes of Imaan Mazari, Hadi Chattha trial appeals as infructuous
Photo: MarkThomas / Pixabay
KEY POINTS
  • The Supreme Court disposed of the appeals as infructuous on Wednesday.
  • A three-member bench headed by Justice Muhammad Ali Mazhar heard the case.
  • The Islamabad High Court will decide whether the petitions are maintainable.
10 yearsSentence for each
22 daysTrial duration in jail
October 29Conviction date

The Supreme Court on Wednesday disposed of appeals against the trial in the barriers removal case involving lawyers Imaan Mazari and Hadi Ali Chattha. It declared the matter infructuous because the trial was already complete.

The appeals were heard by a three-member bench headed by Justice Muhammad Ali Mazhar. According to The Express Tribune, he observed: "The trial has already been completed, and the case has now become infructuous." The court noted that the matter is pending before the Islamabad High Court and said that court would decide whether the petitions are maintainable.

Advocate Faisal Siddiqui told the bench that the anti-terrorism court completed the trial in jail within 22 days. He was also quoted as saying: "Even if you hang us, at least hear the case," and "Let people retain at least the right to have their cases decided."

On October 29, an anti-terrorism court sentenced Imaan and Hadi to 10 years in prison each. They were convicted under PPC Section 186 and given one year's simple imprisonment with a Rs50,000 fine each. Under PPC Section 353 they received two years' simple imprisonment with a Rs50,000 fine each. Under Section 7(h) of the Anti-Terrorism Act, 1997 they received 10 years' rigorous imprisonment with a Rs100,000 fine each.

The two were arrested by capital police in October 2024 after a confrontation with traffic police who had set up barricades for the visiting English cricket team. The anti-terrorism court framed charges on October 7 and recorded statements from all seven prosecution witnesses. The trial was moved to Adiala Jail amid disputes over the accused's production in court and lawyers' access to them, and the verdict was reserved after it concluded there.

On October 26, the couple had approached the Supreme Court against an Islamabad High Court decision on their request to halt the trial. The High Court had dismissed their request for an interim order against removing anti-terrorism provisions from the case, but issued notices on their plea to suspend the trial.

Imaan and Hadi filed appeals against their convictions in the Islamabad High Court on Friday, along with applications seeking suspension of sentences and bail pending appeal.

Background

khabr.pk reported on 3 November that an Islamabad anti-terrorism court granted bail to Imaan Mazari and Hadi Ali Chattha in a police clash case involving allegations of blocking a road. On 6 November we reported that they had appealed their 10-year sentences in the Islamabad High Court and sought suspension of the sentences and release until the appeals are decided.

Why it matters for Pakistan

The ruling sends the lawyers' challenge back to the Islamabad High Court, where their appeals against conviction and requests for suspension of sentences and bail are pending. The two are serving 10-year sentences, so the High Court's handling of those requests determines their next legal step. The case also involves questions about how quickly a trial was completed in jail, which Advocate Faisal Siddiqui raised before the bench.

Report an error

Supreme CourtImaan MazariIslamabad High Court

Related news

Latest