Just in
PakistanVerified by 3 independent sources

LHC: Sales tax can't be recovered before mandatory registration

The Lahore High Court has ruled that the Inland Revenue department cannot recover sales tax for the period before a person or company is registered under the Sales Tax Rules. The bench dismissed four tax references filed by the department.

LHC: Sales tax can't be recovered before mandatory registration
Photo: U.S. Air Force photo by Airman 1st Class Joseph B… / Wikimedia Commons
KEY POINTS
  • LHC says tax for the pre-registration period cannot be recovered until mandatory registration is completed.
  • The court dismissed the department's four references and upheld the Tribunal's 15 March 2022 orders.
  • A ghee and cooking oil supply case covering 2016-2019 was declared null and void.
4References dismissed
15 March 2022Tribunal orders upheld
2016-2019Ghee and oil case period

The Lahore High Court has ruled that the Inland Revenue department cannot collect sales tax from a person or company for the period before registration until mandatory registration has been completed under the Sales Tax Rules. Nawa-i-Waqt and Daily Pakistan reported the ruling, and 24 News Business, citing the 24NewsHD TV channel, said it came on Friday.

According to Daily Pakistan, the decision was given by a division bench of Justice Hassan Nawaz Makhdoom and Justice Muhammad Ajmal Zahid. 24 News Business reported that Justice Muhammad Ajmal Zahid announced that section 3 of the Sales Tax Act can be invoked against a businessman only after registration.

The court held that a registered person is subject to the Act and its rules from the date of mandatory registration. It said the department must first register a person who is liable under the law before it imposes tax under section 3 and acts on past violations.

The court said the Federal Board of Revenue must first follow the prescribed legal sequence. In the court's words as reported by 24 News Business: "FBR must first follow the prescribed legal sequence to register a person liable to be registered. Only after registration can the department proceed to determine and recover tax."

The bench also said financial laws must be interpreted according to their clear words, and that the department cannot treat notional registration as a substitute for actual registration.

The court rejected all four tax references submitted by the Inland Revenue department on sales tax. It upheld the Appellate Tribunal's decision and maintained the Tribunal's orders dated 15 March 2022.

In the case concerning the supply of ghee and cooking oil between 2016 and 2019, the court declared the proceedings null and void. It directed the department to register first and then collect tax, 24 News Business reported.

Background

khabr.pk reported on 7 November that the FBR added a facility to its IRIS system to amend or cancel electronic sales tax invoices after the 72-hour limit, with prior approval from the concerned Commissioner Inland Revenue.

Why it matters for Pakistan

Businesses and taxpayers in Pakistan are affected by when the FBR can collect sales tax. Under the ruling, as reported, the department must register a liable person first before it determines and recovers tax for earlier periods. Traders facing demands for the period before their registration may be affected by this approach.

Report an error

Lahore High CourtSales taxFBR

Related news

Latest